Most cottage food laws require direct-to-consumer transactions, but the phrase gets tested by real sales situations that the original legislation didn't anticipate. Three common gray areas operators ask about:
Gift orders: A customer pays you to make a product intended for a third-party recipient. This is almost universally still a direct sale — you're transacting with the buyer directly, and the recipient is simply the end user. The exception arises when the buyer is a business ordering for its employees or clients. Several states treat this as a wholesale transaction rather than a consumer sale, which may fall outside your cottage food exemption. If you receive a corporate gift order, confirm how your state classifies the transaction before accepting.
Subscription or CSA-style box pickups: A recurring weekly or monthly food subscription collected at your home, your market booth, or a community drop point is consistently treated as direct-to-consumer across states that have addressed it. The subscription structure and recurring nature don't change the channel classification.
Third-party local delivery apps: Platforms that dispatch a driver to collect your product and deliver it to the customer introduce a third party into what was intended as a two-party direct transaction. Most state cottage food laws were written before these platforms existed, and regulatory guidance is still catching up. Some states have issued explicit guidance excluding app-facilitated delivery from the cottage food exemption. Others haven't addressed it at all, leaving operators in a genuine gray area. If you want to use a delivery platform, contact your state agriculture department and request written guidance before your first listing goes live — not after.